It's your average Friday night in October, with Sharol enjoying her evening reading scary stories while enjoying junk food. But hark, Mrs. Calamine calls and needs you to keep an eye on little Suzie, as Granny is having a medical emergency. Given the situation, Sharol readily agrees to the emergency job. However, fate has other plans in store, but at the end of it all a job will still need to be done. It'll be up to the player to see how it all works out in Babysitting is Murder!